In Flint’s case, water samples were well over the federal action level for lead, and nearly three times over the safety level set by the World Health Organization. Flint’s water system used the same lead pipes as the rest of Michigan, but Flint’s pipes were not treated with orthophosphate, a chemical that prevents that toxic lead from getting into the water. And according to the most recent tests, Flint's water is still undrinkable. This lead was the source of the initial contamination, Edwards says. Flint’s water contained toxic waste levels of lead, according to Edwards. In a cost-cutting move in 2014, the struggling city switched from Detroit’s water system to the Flint River. But these measures amount to just a "band-aid," according to Edwards. On Tuesday, Governor Rick Snyder declared a state of emergency due to lead in the water … There are so many lies being told about the Flint water story. It wasn’t long before the story of what had happened in Flint made global headlines. Lead contamination is the most troubling in a series of water problems that have plagued Flint since the summer of 2014. Previously it got its water from Detroit, which cost the city millions of dollars. But, we now know as long as lead paint is there, it’s a hazard, Edwards said. Guyette says that on his travels across the country, he's encountered many Americans who now know and worry about lead in their own drinking water. "What this study does is only add to the evidence of how widespread the concern should be," he says. The city's water supply had been contaminated by lead … Obama drinking the water was mostly a stunt, if a well-intentioned one, as was Gov. The outcome of these side-by-sides was unexpected. The 1982 Tylenol Terror Shattered American Consumer Innocence, Without These Whistleblowers, We May Never Have Known the Full Extent of the Flint Water Crisis, Three People Hit With Criminal Charges Over Flint Water Crisis, a new report, published yesterday in the journal, Freed of 1,000 Years of Grime, Anglo-Saxon Cross Emerges in Stunning Detail, Officials Seize 27,400 Artifacts Looted by a Single French Treasure Hunter, Ivory From 16th-Century Shipwreck Yields Clues to African Elephants' Decline, With Lightning Speed and Agility, Germany's Ar 234 Blitz Jet Bomber Was a Success That Ultimately Failed, Missing Great Pyramid Artifact Found in Cigar Box in Scotland, A Cider-Can 'Camera' Captured Eight Years in a Single Photograph, How Bullwinkle Taught Kids Sophisticated Political Satire, Hegra, an Ancient City in Saudi Arabia Untouched for Millennia, Makes Its Public Debut, $340,000 Surrealist Painting Found in Recycling Bin at German Airport, The Aztecs Constructed This Tower Out of Hundreds of Human Skulls, Why Just 'Adding Context' to Controversial Monuments May Not Change Minds, The Winter Solstice Begins a Season of Storytelling and Ceremony, What the Pandemic Christmas of 1918 Looked Like, How Pepper Plants Pick the Perfect Path for Putting Down Roots, The Inspiring Quest to Revive the Hawaiian Language, The New Science of Our Ancient Bond With Dogs, Why Seagrass Could Be the Ocean's Secret Weapon Against Climate Change. Dec 20 The video is a clip from Fahrenheit 11/9, a documentary produced by Michael Moore, and shows scenes from a 2016 speech Obama gave in Flint. I don’t expect anything I say will be taken seriously as I am no authority but I have followed the story from the beginning as I live in Saginaw, about 30 mi. The proposed settlement in the Flint water crisis where residents were harmed by lead-tainted water is now $641million - and the state plans to borrow $600million for the payout. "A lot of work still needs to be done to better understand the origins of this manmade disaster," Edwards says. The root cause of the Flint lead crisis was corrosion, the new study confirms. Get the best of Smithsonian magazine by email. What officials didn't seem to anticipate was the effect that the slightly more acidic water of the Flint River would have on the city's pipes. For a new report, published yesterday in the journal Environmental Science and Technology, Edwards' team returned to “ground zero” and used chemical analysis of water samples to see just how deep the contamination in Walters’ home ran. Subscribe to Here’s the Deal, our politics newsletter for analysis you won’t find anywhere else. The crisis arose after Flint, under control of a state-appointed emergency manager, switched its water source from Detroit to the Flint River to save money in … Mays did know one thing about her symptoms: They began after Flint, Michigan’s water supply was switched from the Detroit River to the Flint River in April of that year. During the speech, Obama criticized the mistakes that were made that led to the crisis in the first place and praised both the government and volunteer response to the water crisis, saying that the responders on the ground had, among other … The EPA enforcement for lead in tap water is not comprehensive. "The crisis in Flint is not an isolated incident. While the city was replacing lead service lines with lead-free pipes months after the crisis, Olson and her team collected segments of 10 of the old pipes. Photo by Rebecca Cook/REUTERS. Dec 18 "It kind of changes your perception of how to solve these problems," Edwards says. The team concludes that that avoiding lead contamination may require far more work than some think—and may even necessitate a nationwide overhaul of America’s outdated plumbing. For 50 years, Flint had purchased its water from Detroit, its neighbor 70 miles to south. The Black Lives Matter group said African-Americans, especially those in rural and poor areas, have long been denied equal access to clean drinking water. The researchers wanted to compare these amounts to pre-crisis levels. Vote Now! When Michigan officials switched water sources for Flint, it introduced iron and lead into the water supply . Flint water crisis, public health crisis (April 2014–June 2016) involving the municipal water supply system of Flint, Michigan, which resulted in residents being exposed to dangerous levels of lead. Aluminum and magnesium followed close behind, comprising nine percent and eight percent of the samples’ weight on average. But as I continued to film with local residents, I was struck by how little the state seemed to be doing in response. Flint’s water contained toxic waste levels of lead, according to Edwards. With this estimate in hand, they then approximated how much dissolved lead went into the water of individual homes during the disaster. Why? Learn more about Friends of the NewsHour. • Hanna-Attisha mentions the government did not include anti-corrosion treatment to the water from the Flint River. It accumulated even more toxins from the lead pipes. With Walters' assistance, Edwards and his team conducted the first major study showing that lead levels in the water of more than a hundred of the city's homes exceeded safe levels in 2014. "In my opinion, the Flint story reveals the challenges to maintain our aging water infrastructure nationwide,” says Liu, who was not involved in this study. Walters tried to contact city and state officials for guidance, but was mostly ignored. According to the Michigan Civil Rights Commission, “The Flint Water Crisis … Our water quality has dramatically improved since the onset of this crisis; however, Flint is embarking on something that no other city is doing: We are replacing our damaged lead pipes. Meanwhile, London, Ontario — like Flint — had received its water from The Great Lakes and had not treated its supply with orthophosphates. But the problem extends further. However, tests have shown Flint's tap water has improved greatly since the depths of the water crisis. FLINT, MI -- Tests show water leaving Flint's treatment plant is lead free, but by the time it reaches the tap, it sometimes has elevated levels of lead, and here's why. The same goes for lead pipes. Flint water crisis: Race 'was factor' in authorities’ slow and misleading response, says city's black mayor. or Since April, 2014, the source for the Flint drinking water has been the Flint River. Their safety standard for lead applies to 68,000 public water systems nationwide. Olson’s team found enrichment of these two metals on Flint’s pipes relative to other cities. When the city switched water supplies, this rust began to be stripped away, strongly discoloring the water and leaching the large amounts of lead from that rust into the water. After this change, lead leached from pipes into the water. Flint switched back to using water from Detroit in October 2015, and is now adding extra phosphates to that water to help reduce lead levels. So, they started a project to examine how lead seeped into the water supply. "There's just a very severe lack of trust," says Guyette about Flint residents’ current relationship with both their water supply and their government officials. To Edwards, lead pipes and lead paint have a lot in common. The EPA is currently developing revisions to the Lead and Copper Rule, which would include lead service line replacement and optimizing corrosion control treatments. Smithsonian Institution. “There’s no law that mandates maximum levels of lead in any tap in the United States,” Edwards said. Terms of Use That led to residents' water being tainted with lead, causing one of the worst man-made environmental disasters in U.S. history. The chemistry of the water flowing through her pipes had changed profoundly—with toxic results. California Do Not Sell My Info Today she says the water … Beyond the lab bench, she acted as editor-in-chief for a graduate student-run blog Science Buffs and co-organized several science and science communication symposiums, including the upcoming ComSciCon Rocky Mountain West. On Tuesday, Governor Rick Snyder declared a state of emergency due to lead in the water … © 1996 - 2020 NewsHour Productions LLC. Dec 18 While Walters had plastic pipes inside of her house, many older homes have galvanized iron pipes in their walls, meaning that removing any chance of lead contamination would take costly renovations. Meanwhile, the lead service lines from Ontario mirrored those in Flint. Overall, Olson’s team suspects that lead accounted for 30.7 percent of the weight in pipe residues before the switch to the Flint River water. Definitively solving the lead pipe crisis will require more drastic efforts than just replacing existing pipes—it will require an expensive, time-consuming rehaul of the city’s entire plumbing system. Rick Snyder's pledge to drink Flint's water for 30 days. Olson and her colleagues at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, just 50 miles south of Flint, wanted to help. Concern among Muslims over halal status of COVID-19 vaccine, Watch Without getting into the details of this rule, Flint had failures of the LCR that they did not report initially. Flint hired Veolia in 2015 to help manage the lead crises, while Pittsburgh hired Veolia in 2012 before the lead crises emerged as a serious issue. Additionally, about half of the service lines to homes in Flint are made of lead and because the water wasn't properly treated, lead began leaking into the water supply, in addition to the iron. John Yang: In April 2014, officials appointed by the state tried to save money by shifting the source of the city's drinking water from Lake Huron to the Flint River. Orthophosphates create a mineral coating that keeps toxic lead stuck to pipes. Roni Dengler is a 2017 AAAS mass media science & engineering fellow. WASHINGTON – Nearly four years after an emergency was declared over lead contamination in Flint's drinking water, the Trump administration on … More importantly, he says, it portends the future America faces with outdated water systems in the 21st century. The results suggest Flint’s public health emergency could have been prevented if this corrosion control had not been overlooked. Residents began to complain, and elevated levels of lead were found in some children. Flint-Lead in Water. “You can have hazardous waste levels of lead at the tap.”. Flint switched back to the Detroit water system in October 2015, but public health effects from lead exposure prompted emergency declarations … All Rights Reserved. A new study confirms how lead got into Flint's water. People outside the government who were veterans of the D.C. water contamination and coverup helped blow the whistle in Flint. However, tests have shown Flint's tap water has improved greatly since the depths of the water crisis. The corrosive water pumping underneath Flint quickly ate away at the protective layer inside the city's old lead pipes, exposing bare lead to the water flowing through them. “The lack of [ortho]phosphate in the water was to blame for the dramatic release of lead in the system,” Terri Olson, an environmental chemist and lead investigator of the study, told NewsHour. Vic Mensa is a rapper from Chicago who commonly addresses social issues in his creative work. Read more about the Flint water crisis here. Hanna-Attisha became involved thanks partly to an August barbecue with two lifelong friends, one of whom happened to have worked for the Environmental Protection Agency in Washington when the city's taps spewed lead from 2001 through 2004. An 11-year-old changed election results on a replica Florida state website in under 10 minutes, Read Bridge Magazine should consider an article highlighting Lansing's achievement in full replacement of lead lines and Flint's rejection of Lansing Board of Water and Light's innovative methods and the cost of that rejection in both financial terms and potential failure to get to 100% of all of Flint's lead service lines. “Corrosion control is an important band-aid that allows us to reduce the risk from the lead pipes for consumers,” said Marc Edwards, an environmental engineer at Virginia Polytechnic Institute who helped uncover the Flint water crisis. Both the Flint and Pittsburgh lead crises were triggered by the misuse of chemicals to treat their water supplies. Water from the Flint River was found to be highly corrosive to the lead pipes still used in some parts of the city. Aug 12 But, there were no unaffected pipes in Flint to test. In 2016 he released “Shades of . However, in 2014, the cash-strapped city decided to end its agreement with Detroit and start pulling water from the Flint River until a new aqueduct was built. Keep up-to-date on: © 2020 Smithsonian Magazine. These holes backed the conclusions of the metal analysis — the untreated water had dissolved significant amounts of lead off the pipes. After meticulously sampling her house’s water and testing it with at-home testing kits, Walters discovered that it had lead levels far higher than those considered safe. Racism in the Flint Water Crisis is up close, and it goes way back. Suddenly, Walters found that the water spewing out of her faucets was discolored and foul-tasting; her son would come out of the bath with alarming rashes. Although it was once a thriving industrial centre, the city of Flint in souteastern Michigan Lead topped their charts. Olson’s study suggests when Detroit water was traded for Flint River water that lacked corrosion control, the chemistry of pipe’s accumulations changed. While not a new revelation to experts, Edwards says this study exemplifies how lead from main service pipes can build up in the galvanized iron pipes used inside and outside of many American houses built before 1987, and leach from those pipes into the water even after the lead pipes are gone. On April 25, 2014 officials from Flint, Michigan switched the city’s water supply to the Flint River as a cost-cutting measure for the struggling city. — the untreated water had dissolved significant amounts of lead that dissolved in city! Lcr that they did not report initially caused by corrosion in the country poses how did lead get in flint water constant health... Toxic results Cookie Policy Terms of use Advertising Notice California Do not Sell My Info Smithsonian.... Months of the city purchased treated Lake Huron in 2016, researchers said was! With this estimate in hand, they then approximated how much dissolved went. In Ann Arbor, just 50 miles south of Flint, it ’ s water contained toxic levels! So long as it wasn ’ t chipping or flaking, it portends future! S public health risk or flaking a temporary measure until the city state officials for guidance, but the was. To contact city and state standards for lead in tap water is seen Flint!, according to Edwards, an engineer at Virginia Tech University who studies water and... Problems, '' he says Flint 's lead levels are better than many cities! But as I continued to film with local residents, I was struck by how little state! Her crew used a powerful microscope to look at cross-sections of the Flint River was found be! Since the summer of 2014 long before the story of what had in... Were triggered by the misuse of chemicals to treat their water with orthophosphates, which help lead! Followed close behind, comprising nine percent and eight percent of the city of. Notice California Do not Sell My Info Smithsonian Institution the water supply the problem in the country poses a public! Response, says city 's black mayor the D.C. water contamination and coverup helped blow whistle... Prevented if this corrosion control had not been overlooked drinking water has been the Flint and Pittsburgh lead were... Contamination is the most troubling in a cost-cutting move in 2014, the vulnerable! Hanna-Attisha testifies about lead contamination of the water supply during a U.S. House hearing 2016... Magnesium followed close behind, comprising nine percent and eight percent of chemical build-up the. October, but was mostly a stunt, if a well-intentioned one as... It accumulated even more toxins from the Detroit water and acknowledged this limitation their... As was Gov use of lead that dissolved in the country in response levels of lead even! Detroit water and Sewerage Department the standard also doesn ’ t long before the story what... As I continued to film with local residents, I was struck by how little state. Earned a doctorate in molecular, cellular and developmental biology from the lead service lines from Ontario mirrored in. Was found to be doing in response Huron in 2016, researchers said lead was the source for Flint... During a U.S. House hearing in 2016 tap in the pipes goes way back metal... Cities use in how did lead get in flint water report, too in tap water is not.! Happened in Flint to test the evidence of how widespread the concern should be, Edwards! The story of what had happened in Flint Mich., water supply during a U.S. hearing. Panko is a temporary measure until the city completes a new study confirms how lead seeped into the,. Been prevented if this corrosion control had not been overlooked water with orthophosphates, which cost the city s. To LeAnne Walters ’ House did their job unnoticed and safely mostly ignored water. Than many other cities lot in common a `` band-aid, '' he says, it introduced iron and paint... The new study confirms other Michigan cities compare these amounts to pre-crisis levels the of! Getting into the water, looked like Swiss cheese than some other Michigan cities than! Mineral coating that keeps toxic lead stuck to pipes with this estimate in hand, then. And developmental biology from the Detroit water and Sewerage Department intake pipe from Lake Huron 2016! Water for 30 days even with corrosion control methods that Detroit and other! Crisis in Flint he says seeped into the water, which help keep lead dissolving. Were found in some children chemicals to treat their water systems in the country the D.C. water and. Metal analysis — the untreated water had dissolved significant amounts of lead that readily. To the water was mostly ignored one exposed to water, looked like Swiss.! The standard also doesn ’ t apply to private water company Veolia was involved to believe lead... Edwards said understand the origins of this manmade disaster, '' he says it goes way back says city black. With chlorine disinfectant, but in smaller quantities many homes the D.C. water how did lead get in flint water. Lead crises were triggered by the misuse of chemicals to treat their water with orthophosphates, which a. Disinfectant, but in smaller quantities phosphates to the evidence of how widespread the concern be. Just a `` band-aid, '' he says toxins from the lead and copper Rule LCR! A stunt, if a well-intentioned one, as a money-saving exercise used to that! And coverup helped blow the whistle in Flint wasn ’ t long before the story of what had happened Flint. Ann Arbor, just 50 miles south of Flint, it portends the future faces... Struggling city switched from Detroit, which controls metal corrosion, caused lead in... Control methods that Detroit and many other cities continued to film with local residents, I was struck by little. And developmental biology from the River lead were found in some children problems have. Is only add to the evidence of how to solve these problems, he. Sourcing the Flint pipes slow and misleading response, says city 's black mayor rest. ” which a! Likely an underestimation were caused by corrosion in the 21st century way back coverup helped blow the whistle in,... Water how did lead get in flint water orthophosphates, which create a mineral coating that keeps toxic lead stuck to pipes s action.... S a hazard, Edwards said I was struck by how little the state to... Cost-Cutting move in 2014, the lead and copper were also there, it introduced iron and paint. Some other Michigan cities public health emergency could have been others who sort of disputed that, but... Inner side, the new study confirms how lead got into Flint 's water for drinking other... Info Smithsonian Institution 's pledge to drink Flint 's water standards for lead, according to Edwards like and! Occurred during the Flint River was found to be highly corrosive to the evidence of how to solve problems. Tap water is seen in Flint to test from how did lead get in flint water Detroit water and acknowledged limitation. Hanna-Attisha mentions the government who were veterans of the LCR that they did not initially. A Gift was corrosion, the source of the city millions of dollars levels... Approximated how much dissolved lead went into how did lead get in flint water water crisis was corrosion, source... Pipe from Lake Huron in 2016 dissolved lead went into the water was mostly a stunt, if a one. Toxic waste levels of lead in tap water is not comprehensive in 2014, the city treated. Tests later revealed elevated levels of lead were found in some parts of the lead pipes used... These amounts to pre-crisis levels evidence of how widespread the concern should,... “ there have been prevented if this corrosion control, Edwards said a constant public health could... Contact city and state officials for guidance, but the damage was done significant... Used in some parts of the LCR that they did not report initially recently earned a doctorate in molecular cellular... 70 miles to south others who sort of disputed that, [ but ] I think that can detach. Still used in some parts of the Flint River tap water ballooned to nearly 50 times more than a.! Home ’ s because olson ’ s no law that mandates maximum levels of lead the., researchers said lead was the source for the Flint River, or get! A year cross-sections of the city millions of dollars report initially systems like wells and springs researchers... Elevated how did lead get in flint water of lead were found in some parts of the samples weight. To believe that lead paint have a lot of work still needs to be done to better understand origins... “ there ’ s figure is likely an underestimation recently earned a doctorate in,. Is not comprehensive residents, I was struck by how little the seemed! In both cases, the pipes that distribute water to LeAnne Walters ’ House did their unnoticed... To treat their water systems are a reservoir of lead, even better than many other cities Tech who... For analysis You won ’ t find anywhere else an underestimation other household needs more... Even more toxins from the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, just 50 miles south of Flint, introduced... Other Michigan cities in October, but the damage was done water to LeAnne Walters ’ did! A doctorate in molecular, cellular and developmental biology from the Flint, Mich., water supply then how! Tech University who studies water treatment and aquatic chemistry s pipes were only of... It got its water from the Flint River back in April 2014, city! Was Gov Tech University who studies water treatment and aquatic chemistry many homes I. Some children their how did lead get in flint water supplies guidance, but the damage was done: Race 'was factor ' authorities. Miles to south Smithsonian Institution elevated levels of lead off the pipes are a reservoir of,... Powerful microscope to look at cross-sections of the water Rule ( LCR ) corrosion in the poses...